If you’re comparing Snyder’s Furniture vs. Peaceful Valley Furniture, you’re looking at two premiumAmish furniture brands known for their exceptional craftsmanship. While both promise quality pieces that last for generations, they take different approaches. Let’s break down what each brand offers so you can choose the right fit for your style, budget, and needs.

About Snyder’s Furniture: The Best Amish Furniture

Snyder’s Furniture is the go-to destination if you want something more customized and unique. They are located in the heart of Lancaster’s Amish community and offer some of the best quality Amish furniture available in the US. 

With decades of experience in handcrafted furniture, they prioritize one-on-one service and personalized designs. Their skilled artisans handcraft all these pieces from premium woods, such as oak, maple, andcherry wood.

Snyder’s has been family-owned and operated since 1983, specializing in fully customizable pieces. They collaborate with local Amish and Mennonite artisans to deliver furniture that perfectly fits your style and space. Every piece comes with a lifetime guarantee. This underscores their commitment to quality.

Snyder’s produces high-quality Amish furniture pieces, likelive-edge tables andsolid wood dressers. 

They also craft bedroom pieces, such as sturdyking-size platform beds with storage, bespoke solid wood chests, and unique pieces likeWindsor-style chairs andsaddle stools. 

About Peaceful Valley Furniture

If you’re looking for a store that combines Amish craftsmanship with modern shopping convenience, Peaceful Valley Furniture could be worth a visit. With three locations in Lancaster County, you can explore a variety of handcrafted pieces without going far.

Since its founding, Peaceful Valley has focused on offering high-quality, handcrafted furniture in a range of wood types. You’ll find oak, pine, maple, and cherry pieces for every room — all built to last. Their locations in Intercourse and Strasburg provide easy access to furniture that balances traditional style with modern needs.

Snyder's Furniture vs. Peaceful Valley: A Comparison

Snyder’s Furniture and Peaceful Valley Furniture both deliver exceptional Amish-crafted furniture using woodworking techniques the craftspeople have passed down through generations. Both brands focus on creating heirloom-quality pieces and offer unique strengths in design and craftsmanship. 

Let’s explore key features like quality, customization, and customer experience so you can pick the best brand for your home.

 

Now let’s look at each of these features in detail: 

1. Product Selection 

Snyder’s Furniture focuses on creating unique, custom-designed pieces that stand out in any room. You’ll find handcrafted dining room sets; oak, maple, andcherry wood bedroom furniture; office furniture; and statement pieces that they tailor to your specifications. 

Whether you need a custom-builtrectangular kitchen table or a one-of-a-kindAmish office desk, Snyder’s prioritizes quality over quantity, making sure that they meticulously craft every piece to meet your needs.

Peaceful Valley takes a broader approach, offering a wide range of semi-custom furniture for every room in your house. Their selection includes outdoor furniture, dining sets, bedroom pieces, living room items, and office furniture. They emphasize variety and accessibility over full customization.

2. Craftsmanship and Materials

Snyder’s takes craftsmanship seriously. They collaborate with localAmish and Mennonite artisans, andhandcraft each piece to order. They use solid wood construction, traditional joinery techniques, and premium conversion varnish that resists liquids, household chemicals, and watermarks, keeping your furniture flawless for a long time. 

Their artisans use mortise-and-tenon joints(a woodworking technique where one piece fits precisely into another without nails or screws), dovetailing, and hand-rubbed oils to produce furniture that not only looks exceptional but also withstands years of use.

Peaceful Valley also emphasizes solid wood construction, focusing on durability and classic designs. They use oak, pine, maple, and cherry, finishing each piece with multiple coats of stain for a polished look. While they adhere to traditional woodworking methods, their focus leans toward producing high-quality, semi-custom pieces quickly.

3. Customization 

Snyder’s specializes in full customization. You can choose from six wood species and over 20 stain options and make modifications to the size, shape, and function of each piece. Want hidden storage or a specific finish? Snyder’s makes it happen through one-on-one consultations with design experts. Lead times range from 8-12 weeks, reflecting the time and care they take with each custom creation.They also offer free interior design consultations.

Peaceful Valley offers a semi-custom experience. You can select the wood type, stain, and hardware while sticking to their established designs. This approach keeps costs down and the lead times short — typically 4-6 weeks — however, it doesn’t allow for extensive customization.

4. Delivery 

Furniture delivery can be expensive, but Snyder’s Furniture prioritizes white-glove service, delivering and installing each custom piece with care. The wait time is slightly longer, but you receive ongoing updates throughout the production process. They alsooffer free delivery on your first order.  

Standard Delivery Times:

• 1-2 weeks for PA, NJ, NY, DE, MD, DC, VA, WV, CT, MA, OH.

• 2-4 weeks for NC, SC, GA, FL (monthly).

• 4-8 weeks for other states.

Peaceful Valley has lead times averaging 1-5 days for their quick-ship items and 1-3 weeks for their regular pieces. They offer white-glove delivery within Pennsylvania and nearby states.

5. Customer Service

Snyder’s takes a personal approach to customer service. You’re not just a customer — you’re a collaborator in creating custom furniture that suits your style and space. The team provides detailed consultations, regular updates throughout the production process, and post-purchase check-ins to ensure your satisfaction.

Peaceful Valley staff can guide you through the selection process. While they excel at providing information and advice, their service leans toward efficiency rather than extensive customization support.

6. Pricing and Value

Thecost of Amish furniture depends on many factors, like the wood species you pick, design complexity, custom detailing, craftsmanship, and the brand.

Snyder’s positions itself as a premium brand, with dining tables starting at $1,000 and going up for fully customized designs. But this premium is worth it because you're paying for bespoke craftsmanship, lifetime guarantees, and exceptional service.Flexible payment plans and layaway options make it easier to invest in heirloom-quality pieces over time.They also offer a 20 years to lifetime warranty. 

Peaceful Valley offers accessible pricing, with small bar dining tables ranging from $550 and upwards for custom pieces. Their semi-custom approach and financing options make quality Amish furniture available to a broad audience.

Snyder's Furniture vs. Peaceful Valley: Which Brand is Right for You?

So, which store should you choose? It depends on what you value most.

Choose Snyder’sif you’re looking for custom-built, heirloom-quality furniture backed by a lifetime guarantee. Their craftsmanship focuses on creating unique, tailored pieces that reflect your specific design preferences and functional needs. If you’re seeking fully custom, heirloom-quality pieces built to your exact specifications, then Snyder’s is a great choice. You’ll get exceptional craftsmanship, extensive design options, and a lifetime guarantee that reflects your investment.

Choose Peaceful Valley if you want a wide variety of furniture styles and quicker delivery. Their semi-custom approach allows you to select wood types, stains, and hardware.

How to Identify Authentic Amish Furniture

Whether you’re shopping at Snyder’s or Peaceful Valley, it’s important to know how to spotgenuine Amish furniture pieces. Here’s how you can tell if you’re getting the real deal:

1. Solid wood construction: Authentic Amish furniture is made from 100% solid wood. If you see particleboard or veneers, it’s not genuine Amish work.

2. Handcrafted details: Genuine Amish furniture shows subtle variations, indicating it’s handmade. If it looks perfectly uniform, it may not be authentic.

3. Natural finishes: Amish furniture typically uses organic oil-based finishes that highlight the wood's natural grain. Avoid synthetic finishes that mask the wood’s beauty.

4. Traditional joinery: This is where artisans fit pieces of wood together without nails or screws for a stronger, longer-lasting build.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Amish furniture from Lancaster County special?

Amish furniture from Lancaster County stands out for its solid wood construction, meticulous craftsmanship, and heirloom-quality pieces that use traditional joinery techniques.

How do Snyder's Furniture and Peaceful Valley differ in their product offerings?

Snyder’s specializes in fully customizable, high-quality pieces, while Peaceful Valley offers a broader range of semi-custom furniture across multiple categories.

What customization options are available at Snyder's and Peaceful Valley?

Snyder’s provides full customization, including six wood species, 20-plus stain options, and tailored design consultations, while Peaceful Valley offers semi-custom options with four wood species and select stain colors.

What are the price ranges for Amish dining tables at both stores?

Snyder’s dining tables start at $1,000 and can exceed $5,000, while Peaceful Valley ranges from $1,200 to $4,000.

Do Snyder's and Peaceful Valley offer delivery services?

Yes, both offer delivery, with Snyder’s providing installation, setup, and ongoing delivery updates, and Peaceful Valley offering white-glove delivery.

How long does it take to receive Amish furniture after ordering?

Snyder’s takes 4-12 weeks for custom pieces, while Peaceful Valley delivers in 4-6 weeks for semi-custom items.

Which store is better for someone on a budget?

Peaceful Valley offers more budget-friendly semi-custom pieces, while Snyder’s higher prices reflect their focus on fully customized, heirloom-quality furniture.

Do these Amish furniture stores have websites or online catalogs?

Snyder’s emphasizes in-person consultations but also offers online ordering. Peaceful Valley provides a comprehensive online catalog as well.

Do Snyder's and Peaceful Valley offer warranties on their furniture?

Yes, Snyder’s includes a lifetime guarantee on all pieces, while Peaceful Valley’s warranties vary by product.